BlogGuides
E-commerce returns: what they really cost a small shop

One click, and Google will show my articles more often in your results.
There is no single verified figure on how much returns weigh on Italian e-commerce: the numbers in circulation range from 5.7% of shipments, according to the Delivery Index run by Netcomm and Poste Italiane, to over 30% of orders according to other estimates with no verifiable source. For a small shop, what actually matters is not the exact percentage, but three concrete costs: who pays for the return shipment, what happens to the goods that come back, and the time spent handling each case.
The numbers in circulation, and the ones that don't hold up
The most quoted figure, around 30% of orders returned in Europe and in Italy, traces back to a 2023 page on the aggregator Statista, which does not publish the methodology behind it, nor whether it actually measures Italy or applies a European average to every country indiscriminately. The same goes for the figure of 2.5 billion euros a year in return costs for Italy, which traces back to an article on a logistics trade website, not to a study with verifiable data. Neither figure has a primary source behind it, so this article does not repeat them as facts.
The most solid figure available comes from Netcomm's Delivery Index, run with Poste Italiane, the Italian e-commerce consortium (checked on 15 November 2026): in the first three quarters of 2025, returns made up 5.7% of total e-commerce shipments in Italy, down from 2024. It is a figure built from actual shipment monitoring, not a survey, but it comes with two limits worth knowing: the full report is reserved to consortium members, so the exact methodology isn't publicly verifiable, and Netcomm is a trade organisation that promotes e-commerce, so it has an interest in showing the phenomenon as under control rather than inflating it. It still remains the most transparent figure available. The same category breakdowns show a higher than average return rate in clothing and electronics, and a lower one in publishing and health and beauty products: the percentage changes a lot depending on what is sold, more than a single national number can tell.
The first cost: who pays for the return shipment
What the website said before the purchase matters more here than what happens afterwards. The baseline rule, set by article 57 of Italy's Codice del Consumo (legislative decree 206/2005, checked on 15 November 2026), says the customer only covers the direct cost of the return shipment. But that rule only applies if the shop informed them, before the order, that this cost would be theirs: if that information is missing, article 49 makes the cost fall on the shop instead, as I explain in more detail in diritto di recesso: i quattordici giorni visti dal lato del negozio online. For a small shop working on thin margins per order, this single missing line in the terms of sale can turn an occasional return into a fixed cost nobody had budgeted for.
The second cost: goods that come back and can't be sold as new again
Not every returned product comes back in a condition fit to sell again. A piece of clothing tried on and then returned, if it shows signs of wear, loses value even when the law still allows the return. For other products the issue doesn't even arise: article 59 of the Consumer Code excludes from the right of withdrawal goods sealed for hygiene or health protection reasons, once the customer has broken the seal after delivery, precisely because that kind of product can no longer be safely resold. Sellers of this kind of item need to disclose it before the purchase, because the exclusion has to be communicated, not simply applied once the return request arrives. For a small shop with no dedicated warehouse staff to inspect, relabel or discount returns, every product that can't be resold as new is a cost that quietly adds to the one from shipping.
The third cost: the time spent handling each case
A return is not just goods moving in the opposite direction. It's an email to read, a product to check on arrival, a decision on whether to put it back on sale, and a refund to process within a set deadline: article 56 of the Consumer Code requires the shop to return everything the customer paid within fourteen days of being informed of the decision to withdraw, even though it can withhold the refund until it receives the product back. In a shop run by one person who also handles stock, shipping and customer support, that time isn't free: it's time not spent finding new customers or fulfilling other orders.
What a seller can do before a return turns into a problem
What the three costs have in common is that none of them disappears entirely: they can only be contained, and the first step is writing them clearly into the terms of sale, before the customer places the order, as I also explain when discussing what to fix on cart abandonment beyond the price: a clear return policy doesn't just reduce disputes after the purchase, it also helps customers decide before it. Sellers of clothing or other return-prone products can also look at whether showing sizing or product details more clearly before the purchase reduces the mistakes that lead to a return, rather than dealing with them afterwards. If you want to check whether your site already states everything the law requires, and whether its product pages give customers the information that prevents avoidable returns, that's something a digital check-up can cover; otherwise get in touch.